Windy City Media Group Frontpage News


home search facebook twitter join
Gay News Sponsor Windy City Times 2023-02-22



Big surprises in second circuit ruling on DOMA
by Lisa Keen, Keen News Service

This article shared 4058 times since Thu Oct 18, 2012
facebook twitter google +1 reddit email

There have been enough federal court rulings declaring the Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional that the Thursday (October 18) ruling by a Second Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals panel was not a big surprise, in and of itself. But the panel's related ruling —that laws should be held to a heightened standard of review when they treat people differently because of their sexual orientation—was news.

In Windsor v. U.S., a three-judge panel vote 2 to 1 that Section 3 of DOMA —which prohibits federal recognition of marriage licenses issued to same-sex couples—is unconstitutional. In doing so, it said that "homosexuals as a group have historically endured persecution and discrimination," that "homosexuality has no relation to aptitude or ability to contribute to society," that "homosexuals are a discernible group," and that gay people, as a class, "remains a politically weakened minority."

For those reasons, said the court, laws treating people differently because they are gay should be given a heightened level of scrutiny by the courts.

"This is the first federal appellate court ruling that heightened scrutiny — a presumption of unconstitutionality — applies in reviewing sexual orientation discrimination; that's definitely a big deal," said Evan Wolfson, head of the national Freedom to Marry group and a long-time legal activist for marriage equality.

"This is huge," agreed Jon Davidson, legal director for Lambda Legal. "When any form of heightened scrutiny applies, it means that courts no longer presume that the law or government conduct that is challenged is constitutional. Instead, they look with suspicion at the government's differential treatment of the minority group.

The decision, and the heightened review ruling, apply only to Second Circuit states for now, but Wolfson said it was an especially impressive find led by Chief Judge Dennis Jacobs, an appointee of President George H.W. Bush. Joining Jacobs in the decision was the appeals court's newest member, Obama appointee Christopher Droney.

Dissenting from the majority was 75-year-old Clinton appointee Chester Straub.

Wolfson noted that the Windsor decision marks the tenth federal ruling that DOMA is unconstitutional.

"No matter how slice it, it's time for the Supreme Court to swiftly strike down this discriminatory law and get the federal government back to treating married couples, gay or non-gay, as what they are: married," said Wolfson.

James Esseks, director of the ACLU's LGBT Project, represented Edith Windsor in the lawsuit. Windsor married her spouse, Thea Spyer, in Canada in 2007. Spyer died in 2009, following a long illness. But because Section 3 of DOMA prohibits the federal government from recognizing the marriages of same-sex couples, Windsor was not allowed to take the routine marital estate tax deduction. Instead, she paid more than $360,000 in taxes on the estate she shared with her spouse.

A legal team hired by the Republican-controlled Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group (BLAG) in the U.S. House argued that, at the time of Spyer's death (in 2009), the state's highest court had ruled (in Hernandez v. Robles, 2006) that the state constitution "does not compel recognition of marriages between members of the same sex."

The Solicitor General appealed the case to the U.S. Supreme Court even before the Second Circuit issued its decision. And constitutional scholar Nan Hunter indicated in her blog that the high court may be inclined to hear Windsor because all nine justices would be able to sit in on the case. Hunter speculated that Justice Elena Kagan would "likely" recuse herself from the Massachusetts cases because she "acknowledged at least limited involvement in discussions of the Gill litigation" while she was Solicitor General.

In its ruling in Windsor, the Second Circuit noted that, "For the purpose of federal estate taxes, the law of the state of domicile ordinarily determines whether two persons were married at the time of death.

In upholding the district court decision that DOMA violates the equal protection clause of the constitution, the majority opinion rejected an argument by BLAG that the U.S. Supreme Court's summary dismissal of an appeal of a 1971 case from Minnesota of a gay couple whose request for a marriage license had been rejected.

"When Baker was decided in 1971, "intermediate scrutiny" was not yet in the Court's vernacular," wrote Jacobs. Citing the Supreme Court's 1996 ruling in Romer v. Evans, he noted, "The Court had not yet ruled that "a classification of [homosexuals] undertaken for its own sake" actually lacked a rational basis." And, referring to the Supreme Court's 2003 ruling striking laws prohibiting same-sex sexual relations, he noted, "And, in 1971, the government could lawfully "demean [homosexuals'] existence or control their destiny by making their private sexual conduct a crime."

The majority said DOMA could not survive an intermediate level of scrutiny. BLAG's claim that DOMA preserves some uniformity in the definition of marriage, it said, failed because "DOMA is an unprecedented breach of longstanding deference to federalism that singles out same-sex marriage as the only inconsistency (among many) in state law that requires a federal rule to achieve uniformity…." And because DOMA affects more than 1,000 federal benefits, it said, BLAG could not persuasively argue that it is substantially related to fiscal matters. The government also failed to prove that DOMA was a means of preserving a traditional understanding of marriage and "responsible childrearing."

The Supreme Court has not yet indicated when it will announce whether it will hear any of the DOMA cases pending before it. Many court observers have speculated the justices are holding off on their decision until after the November 6 election.

© 2012 by Keen News Service. All rights reserved.

This article shared 4058 times since Thu Oct 18, 2012
facebook twitter google +1 reddit email


Gay News

WORLD Japanese poll, Sydney Mardi Gras, mpox, rugby study, soccer player 2023-02-19
- Sixty-four percent of respondents to a Kyodo News poll believe same-sex marriage should be recognized in Japan, the media outlet noted. In the telephone survey, 88.4% also said recent remarks hostile to LGBTQ+ people by a ...

Gay News

Gay Calif. lawmakers introduce Prop 8 repeal 2023-02-14
- On Valentine's Day, two gay California lawmakers introduced a constitutional amendment to repeal Prop 8—the state's same-sex marriage ban that remains on the books despite being ruled unconstitutional years ago, according to The Bay Area Repo ...

Gay News

WORLD Church of England, Japanese officials, Hong Kong ruling, drag kings 2023-02-11
- The Church of England has voted to bless same-sex marriages for the first time in its history; however, its ban on conducting ceremonies will stay in place, PinkNews reported. It was approved after a six-year consultation ...

Gay News

WORLD Indian marches, delegation in Cuba, anti-LGBTQ+ investigation 2023-01-15
- Hundreds of people took part in the first Delhi Queer Pride march in three years as pressure grows for legal recognition of same-sex marriage in India, The Manila Times noted. In March, the South Asian's top ...

Gay News

NATIONAL Testifying in D.C., Brittney Griner, marriage law, school policies 2022-12-18
- WARNING: This week's news contains graphic content. Survivors of the Club Q shooting in Colorado Springs that killed five people and injured approximately 20 others joined GLAAD and other advocates in providing testimony before the House ...

Gay News

Cook County's Kevin Morrison attends signing of Respect for Marriage Act at the White House 2022-12-13
-- From a press release - Washington D.C. — December 13thth 2022 — Cook County Commissioner Kevin Morrison attended the signing of the historic Respect for Marriage Act recently passed by both chambers of congress. The bill guarantees the federal rights ...

Gay News

With President Biden's signature, Respect for Marriage Act is law 2022-12-13
-- From a press release - WASHINGTON — The Human Rights Campaign (HRC) — the nation's largest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ+) civil rights organization — celebrated today as President Biden signed the Respect ...

Gay News

President Biden signs Respect for Marriage Act into law; groups and leaders respond 2022-12-13
-- From press releases - In response to President Biden signing the Respect for Marriage Act into law, groups and leaders release statements. ...

Gay News

Respect for Marriage Act passage important step but not equity says LGBTQIA+/ally Catholic group 2022-12-09
-- From a press release - Dec. 8, 2022. DignityUSA, the nation's foremost organization of Catholics working for justice, equality, and full inclusion of LGBTQIA+ people in our church and society, is pleased that both houses of Congress have now passed the ...

Gay News

Groups and leaders celebrate passage of the Respect for Marriage Act 2022-12-08
-- From press releases - U.S. Representative Mike Quigley: Washington, D.C.— Today, U.S. Representative Mike Quigley (IL-05), Vice-Chair of the Congressional LGBTQ+ Equality Caucus, released the following statement celebrating the passage of ...

Gay News

Congress passes Respect for Marriage Act, sends to President Biden for signature 2022-12-08
-- From a press release. Video below - (New York, NY - December 8, 2022) — GLAAD, the world's largest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) media advocacy organization, is responding to the passage of the Respect for Marriage Act in the U.S. ...

Gay News

WORLD Japan ruling, Kenya groups, World Cup, Almodovar 2022-12-04
Video below - A district court in the Tokyo Prefecture ruled that Japan's constitutional ban on same-sex marriage is legal, according to The Washington Blade. In a statement to Reuters, plaintiffs' attorney Nobuhito Sawasaki said, "This is actually a ...

Gay News

NATIONAL Trans officials, marriage equality, Karl Schmid, Pelosi, Buttigieg 2022-12-04
Video below - Once all of the newly elected officials are seated, there will be nine transgender state legislators (up from eight this year) and nine non-binary state legislators across the country, NBC News noted, citing The Victory Institute. ...

Gay News

Landmark step toward equality: Senate passes bipartisan Respect for Marriage Act 2022-11-29
-- From press releases - WASHINGTON — The Human Rights Campaign (HRC) — the nation's largest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ+) civil rights organization — today celebrated the bipartisan passage of the Respect ...

Gay News

NATIONAL Respect for Marriage Act, lesbian judge, gay official resigns 2022-11-20
- Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-New York) said that debate on the Respect for Marriage Act (RFMA) is suspended and will continue on Nov. 28, when the Senate reconvenes after Thanksgiving, LGBTQ Nation reported. The RFMA ...


Copyright © 2023 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. PDFs for back issues are downloadable from
our online archives. Single copies of back issues in print form are
available for $4 per issue, older than one month for $6 if available,
by check to the mailing address listed below.

Return postage must accompany all manuscripts, drawings, and
photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no
responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.
All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago
Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) will be treated
as unconditionally assigned for publication purposes and as such,
subject to editing and comment. The opinions expressed by the
columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators are
their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual and Transegender News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times
(a Chicago Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender News and Feature
Publication) does not indicate the sexual orientation of such
individuals or groups. While we encourage readers to support the
advertisers who make this newspaper possible, Nightspots (Chicago
GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay, Lesbian
News and Feature Publication) cannot accept responsibility for
any advertising claims or promotions.






About WCMG      Contact Us      Online Front  Page      Windy City  Times      Nightspots
Identity      BLACKlines      En La Vida      Archives      Advanced Search     
Windy City Queercast      Queercast Archives     
Press  Releases      Join WCMG  Email List      Email Blast      Blogs     
Upcoming Events      Todays Events      Ongoing Events      Bar Guide      Community Groups      In Memoriam     
Privacy Policy     

Windy City Media Group publishes Windy City Times,
The Bi-Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 • PH (773) 871-7610 • FAX (773) 871-7609.