WINDY CITY TIMES
Lesbian palimony decision calls on common-law marriage rules
by Matt Simonette
This article shared 907 times since Mon Aug 22, 2016
The Illinois Supreme Court, on Aug. 18, ruled that a lesbian was not entitled to a share of her longtime-partner's medical practice, though the couple were together nearly three decades.
Eileen Brewer, a Cook County judge, and Dr. Jane Blumenthal split in 2008, long before marriage equality was signed into law in 2013. Brewer and Blumenthal had also raised three children together.
A 1979 ruling, Hewitt v. Hewitt, barred such claims, so Brewer's attorneys wanted courts to rule that that decision was now outdated, given that legal recognition of cohabitation and same-sex relationships had significantly broadened in the decades since. But Blumenthal's attorneys maintained that Hewitt v. Hewitt was decided mainly on the basis of Illinois' longstanding rejection of common-law marriage. Illinois is one of only three states that does not allow property-division claims between unmarried partners.
In their Aug. 18 5-2 ruling, the state Supreme Court was largely unmoved by Brewer's position. Among their determinations was that subsequent recognition of same-sex relationships, which Brewer tried to use to bolster her claims, had come about from mainly legislative change, not legal precedent.
"Brewer's argument that we should recognize new public policy justifications to support her counterclaim is further undermined by the fact that all of the public policy changes to which she cites resulted not from judicial action but from the legislature. In each example, it was the legislature, not the courts, that determined what Illinois public policy was ( or was not ) to be," said the decision, authored by Justice Lloyd A. Karmeier.
San Francisco-based National Center for Lesbian Rights ( NCLR ) assisted Chicago Attorney Angelika Kuehn with Brewer's defense.
In a statement, NCLR Legal Director Shannon Minter said, "The Court's ruling today is a devastating blow to unmarried couples and their families. As the dissent points out, the majority's opinion ignores the reality of families and will cause serious harms to countless individuals who are barred from bringing the same common law claims available to all other people in Illinois, solely because they were in a non-marital relationship. Whether a couple decides to marry or not, all of us are equal before the law. Today's decision is a huge step backward for Illinois, which is now dramatically out of step with the rest of the country and with basic principles of fairness and equal access to the courts."
This article shared 907 times since Mon Aug 22, 2016
| ARTICLES YOU MIGHT LIKE|
|LGBT HISTORY MONTH Angela Davis, revolutionary |
By Victoria A. Brownworth - "You have to act as if it were possible to radically transform the world. And you have to do it all the time," said Angela Davis, 78, the country's most famous living revolutionary. She was born ...
|LGBT History Month: Staten Island museum throws open Austen's closet door|
It's been a long time coming, but officials at the Alice Austen House on New York's Staten Island have thrown open the closet door, now fully embracing the lesbian pioneer and photographer who lived in the ...
|LGBT History Project: Tee A. Corinne: Photographer of lesbian sexuality |
By Victoria A. Brownworth - Over her decades as a lesbian photographer and artist, Tee Corinne said, "I'm one of the most obscure famous artists." Famous? Yes. Obscure? Certainly not within artistic circles nor within the queer art world where she ...
|Dozens of celebrities, companies set to take part in Spirit Day on Oct. 21|
--From a press release - New York, NY, Thursday, October 14, 2021 - Today, GLAAD, the world's largest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) media advocacy organization, announced a preliminary list of celebrities, shows ...
|LGBTQ History Month: Pauli Murray, architect of history |
By Victoria A. Brownworth - (Note: The pronouns she/her are used in keeping with Murray's own writings, but Murray was a transmasculine and gender-nonconforming lesbian.) Some say Pauli Murray is the most important U.S. activist many have never heard of. An ...
|MUSIC Janis Ian's last Chicago concert May 14|
In what is being advertised as her last concert in Chicago, LGBTQ singer Janis Ian will be performing at the Old Town School of Folk Music, 4544 N. Lincoln Ave. on Saturday, May 14, 2022, at 8 p.m. Tickets ($48-$50) will ...
|President Biden appoints Debra Shore to key EPA position |
--From a press release - Washington, DC — Today President Joe Biden appointed former LGBTQ Victory Institute board chair Debra Shore to be the next Region Five Administrator for the Environmental Protection Agency — representing six states in the Midwest and ...
|Donations needed for LGBTQ+-affirming spiritual leader's recovery|
In July, Sofia G. Sarabia—an activist and community leader who provided spiritual counseling to LGBTQ+ youth and undocumented immigrants—suffered an unexpected stroke that injured her brain and left her immobile and unable to speak or eat. ...
|Achy Obejas' bilingual poetry book Boomerang/Bumeran explores immigration, liberation|
By Max Lubbers - Achy Obejas is a Cuban-American writer, translator and activist. Boomerang/Bumerán, her newest book, confronts questions of immigration, love and liberation. Like a boomerang, these ideas return throughout the collection, even ...
|SHOWBIZ 'Drag Race' winners, Playboy, punk band, The Dinah, Daniel Craig|
Video below - As part of VH1's #LGBTQHerstoryMonth project, five winners from the RuPaul's Drag Race winner's circle—season one's BeBe Zahara Benet, All Stars 4 winner Monet X Change, season 11 winner Yvie Oddly, season 12 victor Jaida Essence ...
|WORLD Japan politics, video games, lesbian tennis player, Mr. Gay World|
LGBTQ+-rights activists were hoping Japan would finally allow same-sex marriage if Taro Kono, who has publicly supported same-sex marriage, became the country's next prime minister—but their hopes were dashed. Japan's ...
|Sally Ride to be among women on U.S. coins next year|
The United States Mint announced the official designs for the first five coins in the American Women Quarters Program. The 2022 coins will recognize the achievements of author/social activist Maya Angelou; physicist/astronaut Dr. Sally Ride, a ...
|Affinity's 'Virtual Black Gold' on Oct. 23|
Affinity Community Servicesa social-justice organization serving the needs of the Black LGBTQ+ community, with a particular focus on Black womenwill hold its "Virtual Black Gold" casino event Saturday, Oct. 23. ...
|Sisters in Cinema, DocuClub providing consulting opportunities to filmmakers|
Sisters in Cinemaa Chicago-based 501(C)3 that aims to center and celebrate Black girls, women and gender non-conforming media makersand DocuClub, a work-in-progress screening series, have entered into a strategic partnership ...
|PHIMC to present second Mary F. Morten Award on Nov. 7|
Public Health Institute of Metropolitan Chicago (PHIMC) announced Chicago Freedom School as the 2021 recipient of the Mary F. Morten Award for Justice. According to a release, "Chicago Freedom School is being recognized for its vital ...