Windy City Media Group Frontpage News


home search facebook twitter join
Gay News Sponsor Windy City Times 2023-09-06



A tale of two murders: Connected or not?
Part One of a Series
by Gretchen Rachel Blickensderfer

This article shared 15409 times since Wed Sep 24, 2014
facebook twitter pin it google +1 reddit email

Fewer than six miles west of the office of Mayor Rahm Emanuel at Chicago's City Hall sits the corner of West Madison Street and North Kilbourn Avenue. It is part of the neighborhood of Austin—a disregarded, neglected backyard obscured by the magnificent opulence of the Chicago loop and kept quietly hidden from the marveling eyes of the record 46.2 million tourists to which Emanuel proudly laid claim in 2012.

On March 29 of that year, Emanuel announced a $7 billion revitalization of the city that would "touch nearly every aspect of the city's infrastructure network." In his accompanying speech, Emanuel pledged "stronger communities and a better quality of life for all of Chicago's families. That's what I mean by building a new Chicago."

In December 2012, Crain's Chicago Business reported that the YMCA in Austin was closing its doors. Less than four months later, Chicago Public Schools announced the closure of four of its schools in the neighborhood. According to the Austin Talks Newsletter, educators at Francis Scott Key, Louis Armstrong, Horatio May and Robert Emmet schools all received notice of the closures on March 21, 2013. The concern of teachers and staff was not so much for their jobs, but the children who would be forced to walk "on their own at a farther distance through an area known for gang activity."

Elce Redmond is the Organizing Director of the South Austin Coalition, a community organization that has been mobilizing residents around Austin's economic and social issues for the past 37 years.

"There were fights to save the schools, there were fights to save the YMCA, there were fights to address the drug and crime problem with jobs," he told Windy City Times. "But the city, the county, the state, no one wants to really hear that. They don't want to solve problems, they want to increase the amount of people going to jail and that makes a lot of money for folks, but it doesn't address any of the concrete issues of the community. None of these leaders want to do that at all."

It was in this environment, on March 28, 2012—the morning before Emanuel's pledge to build a new Chicago—that a 22-year-old transgender woman of color named Eisha Love, along with another young trans* woman who has since been identified by friends and family members as Donta "Tiffany" Gooden, 19, were allegedly subjected to a verbal and then physical assault by two men at a Citgo station on the Austin corner of West Madison Street and North Kilbourn Avenue.

Love and Gooden fled in Love's vehicle with the two men allegedly pursuing on foot. Two more men reportedly joined the chase in a blue Pontiac. One and a half blocks north of the Citgo, Love lost control of her car. It jumped the curb, striking the lower left leg of one of her pursuers. Using male pronouns and Love's birth name, the arrest report stated that, at the time, Love was "in fear for 'his' safety." According to Love's mother, a group of male bystanders at the scene of the accident told Love "we're going to get you." [For the full report on the Eisha Love case, see last week's Windy City Times print and online editions.]

Love was subsequently placed under arrest at the District 11 police station on West Harrison Street on a charge of aggravated battery. An April grand jury then indicted her on a charge of "attempted first degree murder" with "intent to kill."

Soon after Love was arrested, another incident happened that may be related. One block east of the Citgo, a rusty viaduct crosses Madison at the corner of Kenton Avenue. It was under this viaduct that some of the transgender women who were engaged in sex work ( locally referred to as "on the stroll" ) with 23-year-old Paige Clay say they last saw Clay getting into a car with an unknown man or group of men. On April 16, 2012, less than a month after Love's arrest, Clay's body was discovered half a mile away from the viaduct in an alley in the 4500 block of West Jackson. She had been shot through the head.

An LGBT advocate and former child welfare worker who asked to be identified as "John" told Windy City Times that he was the man who identified Clay's body at the morgue and then had the task of informing her family of her death—a memory that haunts him to this day.

"Paige loved life. She was a strong-willed individual," he told Windy City Times. "Paige wanted to work in the fashion industry. Paige had the skills to be successful on so many levels but didn't have the services and support mechanisms around her to do that and that's why she had to resort to the kind of life that she had. We have a public school system that has let trans* people down. It's not inclusive enough to trans* individuals and is doing nothing help nurture them. Trans* women of color come out of it totally unprepared and they have to rely on prostitution as a means of survival. We may not like to think about it, but it's their truth. It's their reality. It was very disheartening for Paige to go on job interviews in retail stores and—even though she was very well put together and more than qualified to do the job—to be denied because she was trans*."

At the time of Clay's death, Brian Turner was a social worker with Taskforce Prevention and Community Services which has provided HIV and STI preventative services in Austin since 1990. In that capacity, he became close to Clay and her death devastated him. He organized a community forum to discuss violence against transgender women of color later that month. During the event, Windy City Times reported that a Taskforce outreach worker said "it saddens me that Paige was brutally murdered and no one cares."

Turner pushed Chicago Police Department ( CPD ) investigators for answers and even started a Facebook page demanding justice for Clay with the goal of ensuring that "another of ours won't be swept under the rug." The page asked anyone with information to get in touch with him.

It was then that Turner said he received an unexpected phone call.

"The CPD contacted me at Taskforce and told me that I was hindering the case and that, if I did not stop, they were going to lock me up," he told Windy City Times. "The detective never said his name but he did threaten me."

"I don't find that hard to believe," John said. "Bottom line, I don't care how many gay and lesbian officers or LGBT liaisons they have, I believe the CPD is an entity that is still very transphobic. They have no concern in finding out who did what in Austin because Paige was a trans* woman. That's just how they operate."

Donta "Tiffany" Gooden may have been another victim connected to the Eisha Love case. She was the one reportedly in the car the day Love was arrested. In an interview with Windy City Times, Gooden's mother—who asked to be identified as "Mary" and prefers to refer to her daughter as Donta—said that both Clay and Gooden were friends who spent a lot of time at Gooden's home before Clay's murder. "[Paige] was calling and coming over," Mary said. "They were kicking it, like women kick it, switching each other's outfits. That's just what they did." She added that the two girls looked very much alike, so much so that when Clay's body was discovered, Mary's family members and friends were genuinely concerned that it was Gooden.

According to Mary, while growing up, Gooden was exceptionally smart, graduating at the top of her class following a three-month educational program that she attended. "Donta got a diploma and everything. I was so proud," Mary said. "And we were so very close. But what with peer pressure and neighborhood pressure, the streets were calling."

She asserted that Gooden only expressed her feminine identity when going out onto those streets. "I knew what Donta was doing," Mary said. "But all you can do as a mother is love your child for who they are, no matter what."

When Clay was found dead, Gooden became noticeably frightened. According to Mary, for the following four months, she would only go out on the stroll as the sun was beginning to rise in the morning. "I knew my child was scared," Mary said. "But Donta didn't want me to worry."

After Clay's funeral, Gooden told her mother that she had been in the car with Love. Despite Mary's repeated questions, she offered little beyond that.

Mary and the family were also trying to cope with the Memorial Day death of Mary's mother. Gooden had told her aunt that she intended to go back to school and get herself together so that she could help shoulder some of the bills.

On the morning of Saturday, Aug. 11, 2012, Gooden and her mother had been enjoying time together as they usually did. Shortly after midnight on Sunday, Gooden inexplicably left the home with a group of neighborhood friends. "It was unusual because Donta had stopped going out at night," Mary said. "I don't think she was going out on the stroll."

It was the last time Mary would see her daughter alive. "I just remember Donta's smile and, after that, I never seen my child again," she said.

When Gooden didn't return home, Mary frantically called everyone she knew before filing a missing person's report with the CPD. "First thing they said was 'you sure you don't want to give it another day or so'?" Mary remembered. "But I knew something had happened to my child. There was an emptiness in my soul. All I could do was pray."

For two days, she heard nothing. Three blocks from where Clay's body was found, there is a line of three abandoned buildings on the corner of South Cicero Avenue and West Jackson Boulevard. It was on the second floor of the center building that Gooden's mutilated body was discovered on Aug. 14, after complaints about an unpleasant smell. She had been stabbed multiple times. "They stabbed my child in the face," Mary said. "They chopped at Donta's neck; there were stab marks around the back area. It was just a mess."

CPD investigators told Mary that Gooden's blood was found in the front hallway leading to the second floor, as if she had been dragged up there. Provided with no more information, Mary desperately tried to piece together the last hours of her daughter's life. "I figured that Donta might have got there and realized it was a set up and got snatched in there," Mary said. "They had pulled the stairs down in the back of that building so there was no way out. So whoever did this knew the area. They knew Donta could holler as loud as she wanted to but, on a Sunday morning, nobody was going to hear."

Witnesses on the floor below said that they heard Gooden fighting for her life. Mary asserted that within three weeks after her daughter's death, the crime scene was torn down. Today, all that is left is an empty lot conspicuously located between boarded-up buildings.

Mary remembered that shortly after her death, a transgender friend of Gooden's told her that threats had been leveled against her daughter's life. "She said that somebody in a green van was looking for Donta," Mary stated. "They were saying they was going to kill her. They were saying they were going to 'get 'his' ass because 'he' was riding in the car'."

Next Week: Part Two examines walking the streets of Austin.

Windy City Times would like to acknowledge the contributions of Channyn Lynne Parker, Joy Morris, Emmanuel Garcia and Project Vida, Jen Richards, the Sex Workers Outreach Project ( SWOP ), Brian Turner, Terry Dean and the Austin Weekly News for their invaluable assistance in this investigation.

See related stories: . . .

This article shared 15409 times since Wed Sep 24, 2014
facebook twitter pin it google +1 reddit email

Out and Aging
Presented By


Gay News

Arrests, fights punctuate battles across Canada over gender diversity in schools
Arrests were reported in the Canadian cities of Ottawa, Halifax, Vancouver and Victoria, among others, on Sept. 20 as opposing groups clashed on how schools address issues of gender identity and how teachers refer to transgender ...

Gay News

Chicago musician, producer and DJ Don Crescendo killed in Avondale stabbing
Chicago's LGBTQ+ nightlife community and allies have rallied around the family and close friends of local longtime musician, producer and DJ Rodney Donovan Taylor, a.k.a. Don Crescendo, in the wake of his death by stabbing last ...

Gay News

Illinois appeals court hears Jussie Smollett request
On Sept. 12, an Illinois appeals court heard oral arguments regarding embattled gay actor Jussie Smollett lying about a racist and homophobic attack, according to the Chicago Sun-Times. The actor himself—sporting a casual beige jacket and ...

Gay News

Protest action to be held at site of Sept. 9 Jason Aldean concert in Tinley Park
The Revolution Club Chicago has announced a protest action against 46- year-old country music star and Nashville resident Jason Aldean outside of his Highway Desperado Tour appearance Sept. 9 at Credit Union 1 Amphitheatre. The protest ...

Gay News

Matthew Shepard film to be shown ahead of 25th anniversary of his death
Ahead of the 25th anniversary of Matthew Shepard's death, a new two-hour documentary has been announced to honor the posthumous impact made by the gay college student who died after being abducted, beaten and left for ...

Gay News

Gilbert Baker Foundation reacts to death of shop owner who flew the rainbow flag
--From a press release - In response to the murder of Laura Ann Carleton over flying the Rainbow flag in her shop in California, the Gilbert Baker Foundation released the statement below. Facebook refused to post the statement as it did not " their standards." ...

Gay News

Breaking down the origins and impact of the 'gay/trans panic defense'
The final episode of the Max documentary series "Last Call: When a Serial Killer Stalked Queer New York" reveals that the man behind the brutal murders and ...

Gay News

Calif. store owner killed over Pride flag display
In California, Cedar Glen business owner Laura Ann Carleton was shot and killed after a dispute over the Pride flag she'd displayed outside her shop, The Advocate reported. Authorities received a report that someone had been ...

Gay News

WORLD Ethiopia, London attack, monument vandalized, British royals
Ethiopian LGBTQ+-rights activists said that authorities are targeting venues frequented by LGBTQ+ people in the nation, particularly in the capital city, Addis Ababa, per The Advocate. In addition, LGBTQ+ Ethiopians ...

Gay News

Man pleads guilty to hate crime at UpRising Bakery
Alsip, Illinois resident Joseph I. Collins, 25, pled guilty on Aug. 16 to committing a hate crime last summer at UpRising Bakery and Cafe, a Lake in the Hills business that was preparing to host a ...

Gay News

Gay opera star, husband plead guilty to sexual assault
David Daniels—one of the opera world's most well-known countertenors—and husband Scott Walters pled guilty in a Houston district court to drugging and raping a young vocalist, grad student Samuel Schultz, in 2010, NPR reported. Schultz was ...

Gay News

Teen suspect arrested in killing of gay dancer
The New York Police Department arrested a suspect in the fatal stabbing of 28-year-old O'Shae Sibley, who was attacked last weekend at a Brooklyn gas station. According to The Advocate, Sibley, a professional dancer, had been ...

Gay News

Suspect arrested in the murder of O'Shae Sibley, GLAAD comments
--From a press release - (New York, NY - August 4, 2023) GLAAD, the world's largest LGBTQ media advocacy organization, is responding to news that the 17-year-old suspect in the stabbing death of 28-year-old O'Shae Sibley has been arrested in New ...

Gay News

NATIONAL Drag news, HIV-bias lawsuit, Disney, Brittney Griner, gay dancer
Swastika flag-toting neo-Nazis, some of them armed, were at a Wisconsin LGBTQ+ Pride celebration that included a drag show, The Advocate reported. Members of the neo-Nazi extremist group Blood Tribe joined other right-wing hate groups, like ...

Gay News

Dancer O'Shae Sibley murdered amid rising violence against LGBTQs; GLAAD highlights trend
--From a press release - At least five LGBTQ people have been murdered in recent weeks, following a dramatic spike in anti-LGBTQ hate and harassment during Pride month. GLAAD: "[O'Shae] Sibley's shocking murder follows a disturbing rise in violence and harassment ...


Copyright © 2023 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. PDFs for back issues are downloadable from
our online archives. Single copies of back issues in print form are
available for $4 per issue, older than one month for $6 if available,
by check to the mailing address listed below.

Return postage must accompany all manuscripts, drawings, and
photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no
responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.
All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago
Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) will be treated
as unconditionally assigned for publication purposes and as such,
subject to editing and comment. The opinions expressed by the
columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators are
their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual and Transegender News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times
(a Chicago Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender News and Feature
Publication) does not indicate the sexual orientation of such
individuals or groups. While we encourage readers to support the
advertisers who make this newspaper possible, Nightspots (Chicago
GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay, Lesbian
News and Feature Publication) cannot accept responsibility for
any advertising claims or promotions.






About WCMG      Contact Us      Online Front  Page      Windy City  Times      Nightspots
Identity      BLACKlines      En La Vida      Archives      Advanced Search     
Windy City Queercast      Queercast Archives     
Press  Releases      Join WCMG  Email List      Email Blast      Blogs     
Upcoming Events      Todays Events      Ongoing Events      Bar Guide      Community Groups      In Memoriam     
Privacy Policy     

Windy City Media Group publishes Windy City Times,
The Bi-Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 • PH (773) 871-7610 • FAX (773) 871-7609.