|
|
Jenner & Block attorneys discuss key LGBT cases
by Mason Harrison 2010-10-06
|
|
This article shared 3255 times since Wed Oct 6, 2010
|
|
Representatives from the law firm Jenner & Block hosted a forum on the state of LGBT equality Oct. 1 at the firm's downtown Chicago offices, addressing the legal minutiae of cases involving the federal Defense of Marriage Act ( DOMA ) , California's Proposition 8, the military's "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" ( DADT ) policy and more.
"Despite setbacks and disappointments," the Jenner representatives noted, "remarkable progress toward LGBT equality continues in the courts. The key change in 2010," they noted, "has been to move to federal courts and federal constitutional challenges [ in several cases ] ." But questions remain about how the Supreme Court will view these issues as the various cases involving LGBT equality move up the judicial ladder.
In the legal challenge to Prop 8the voter-approved ban on same-sex marriagethe issue of whether or not the defendants, who are private citizens and not the state's attorney general, have standing remains an open question. The case is now before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
In July, a federal judge in Boston ruled that the federal government's refusal, embodied in DOMA, to recognize same-sex married couples is a violation of the Constitution's requirement of equal protection. The judge rejected several justifications for the law, stating that morality, the need for procreation and the issue of state sovereignty were not valid reasons to uphold the ban.
The attorneys also discussed the ban on openly gay servicemembers. Until recently, they noted, all challenges to DADT failed in court. Deference to the military drove the reasoning in every opinion. But in September of this year, a federal judge ruled that Air Force Maj. Margaret Witt be reinstated to her military job after being discharged under DADT. The ball is now in the Obama administration's court, which iswhile calling for a repeal of the lawobligated to defend federal statutes.
Speakers also highlighted a Supreme Court case involving a conservative Christian student organization at the Hastings College of the Law in San Francisco. The group banned "unrepentant" gays and lesbians from joining the organization. College officials refused to provide funding and official recognition to the group because of its stance. The group sued and the case made its way to the Supreme Court where the justices found that the school's "all-comers" policy was constitutional.
In Washington state, anti-gay activists sought to repeal the state's domestic partnership law and wanted the names of their supporters who signed petitions to be exempt from being viewed in public records. But the Supreme Court disagreed and ruled that the state's disclosure requirements are "modest." The activists claimed that there was a need to keep the signers' names from the public because they feared their supporters would be targeted by LGBT activists. The court also jettisoned that argument, and stated that "harsh criticism" from one's opponents is the price one must pay for democracy. |
|
|
|
This article shared 3255 times since Wed Oct 6, 2010
|
ARTICLES YOU MIGHT LIKE |
---|
|
| | NATIONAL Missouri measure, HIV/AIDS Awareness Day, judge, Texas schools 2024-03-15 - In Missouri, a newly proposed law could charge teachers and counselors with a felony and require them to register as sex offenders if they're found guilty of supporting transgender students who are socially transitioning, CNN noted. ...
|
| | State Rep. Kelly Cassidy attacked on social media, allegedly by backers of Burke 2024-02-26 - Illinois state Rep. Kelly Cassidya supporter of Cook County state's attorney Democratic candidate Clayton Harris IIIposted on social media that a backer of Eileen O'Neill Burke, who's running against Harris ...
|
| | SHOWBIZ Kristen Stewart, Rock Hudson, Talia Keys, 'True Detective,' Marvel comic 2024-02-23 - At the Berlin Film Festival, Kristen Stewart defended her photo shoot for a Rolling Stone magazine cover that went viral and divided audiences on social-media platforms, per The Hollywood Reporter. "The existence of a female body ...
|
| | NATIONAL Utah board member, Baths founder dies, Fla. protests, DoJ equity plan 2024-02-16 - Utah's Republican governor and lieutenant governor urged the State Board of Education to take action against a conservative board member whose social-media post questioning the gender of a high school basketball player incited threats against the ...
|
| | Scott Free's new album revives protest music for the modern era 2024-01-09 By Alec Karam - Gay Chicago musician Scott Free wants to bring protest music back to the mainstream. With his new album Songs to Fight Oppression, Free has unveiled several new sing-along social justice songs to accompany protests, or simply ...
|
| | NATIONAL Social Security, NBJC grants, Discord's policy, Sam Altman, Ohio deaths 2023-12-14 - A nonbinary former employee of the U.S. Social Security Administration, identified as "J. Doe," filed suit against the agency, claiming workplace misgendering forced them to resign, Philadelphia Gay News reported. Doe claims that constant misgendering at ...
|
| | Angelica Ross talks politics, Hollywood, Buddhism and more 2023-12-13 - Angelica Ross had already made her imprint on society in various ways. She is the founder of TransTech Social Enterprises, which helps transgender and gender-nonconforming people become part of the tech industry; an activist who hosted ...
|
| | WORLD Queer teen dies, trans activist honored, HIV drugs, mpox, British lesbian 2023-12-01 - In India, queer makeup artist Pranshu reportedly died by suicide—at age 16—after being subjected to relentless attacks online, PinkNews noted. On social media, LGBTQIA+-rights advocacy collective Yes, We Exist claimed ...
|
| | NATIONAL Bishop removed, business news, Jezebel shutting down, MAP head 2023-11-17 - Pope Francis removed the bishop of Tyler, Texas—a conservative prelate active on social media who has been a fierce critic of the pontiff, PBS reported. A one-line statement from the Vatican said the pope had "relieved" ...
|
| | HRC's 2023 survey of cities, towns shows record support for LGBTQ+ residents; Chicago scores 100 2023-11-16 --From a press release - WASHINGTON—Te Human Rights Campaign Foundation (HRC), in partnership with the Equality Federation, an advocacy accelerator rooted in social justice that builds power in a network of state-based LGBTQ+ advocacy organizations ...
|
| | PASSAGES: Longtime social justice activist, filmmaker, writer Amber Hollibaugh 2023-10-27 - Longtime social justice and HIV/AIDS activist, filmmaker, public speaker and writer Amber Hollibaugh died Oct. 20 due to complications from type one diabetes in her Brooklyn, New York home. She was 77. A self-described "lesbian sex ...
|
| | NATIONAL White House, school news, LGBTQ+ deaths, Navy petty officer honored 2023-10-13 - The White House condemned conservative social-media activist Chaya Raichik for ridiculing openly gay Interior Department official Tyler Cherry on the site X (formerly Twitter), describing her posts as "cruel and unacceptable" ...
|
| | OPINION Social media use, mental health literacy and related problems among LGBTQ+ youth 2023-09-23 - Special to Windy City Times Depression levels in the United States have risen steadily over the past five decades, and steep increases have been observed in recent years among children, adolescents, and adults under 25 years ...
|
| | Brave Space Alliance holds Post Pride Mixer 2023-08-30 - On Aug. 27, Brave Space Alliance held its Post Pride Mixer at popular lesbian-owned bar Nobody's Darling. The social gathering celebrated past accomplishments while looking forward to new horizons for both the service organization and the ...
|
| | Iraq banning media from saying 'homosexuality' 2023-08-10 - Iraq's official media regulator has ordered all media and social-media companies operating in the country not to use the term "homosexuality" and to say "sexual deviance" instead, NBC News reported. The Iraqi Communications and Media Commission ...
| |
|
|