Windy City Media Group Frontpage News

THE VOICE OF CHICAGO'S GAY, LESBIAN, BI, TRANS AND QUEER COMMUNITY SINCE 1985

home search facebook twitter join
Gay News Sponsor Windy City Times 2023-12-13
DOWNLOAD ISSUE
Donate

Sponsor
Sponsor
Sponsor

  WINDY CITY TIMES

Dahir Views: Lesbian Mother Torn From Children
by Mubarak Dahir
2006-01-25

This article shared 5825 times since Wed Jan 25, 2006
facebook twitter google +1 reddit email


DONNA ELLIS' FINGERPRINTS ARE ALL OVER THE lives of her two little girls.

There she was, with her partner, holding the younger daughter at the girl's baptism at Joy Metropolitan Community Church in Orlando.

For six years she coached the older girl's little league team.

There are shoeboxes full of photographs and DVDs of the stuff of family life: the dance recitals, a trip to Disney World and of the younger girl, when she was just three years old, running through a gaggle of geese at the petting zoo. And there is Ellis, eating the chocolate cake baked by a light bulb in the girls' Easy-Bake oven, shooting baskets with the girls in the driveway.

These are the tangible memories of a mother raising her kids.

But Donna Ellis is no longer allowed to be with the children she spent nearly 10 years mothering. In fact, she has not seen the two girls, the older who is now 13 and the younger who is now 7, for several years.

______

ON A BEAUTIFUL SPRING DAY last year, Mark Hoefen and his partner, Rolando Martin, went for a swim and then to a Chinese restaurant to order dinner. While they waited outside for their food, Hoefen suddenly fell to the ground and hit his head on the pavement.

He was rushed to the hospital, where doctors initially told Martin his partner was going to be fine. But he wasn't. On April 2, 2005, Hoefen died at Tampa General Hospital in Florida.

While there is no evidence at this point that the hospital did anything wrong in treating Mark Hoefen, his partner and parents have raised serious questions about his care and his unexpected death.

But even if Mark Hoefen had been the victim of medical malpractice, it appears there is nothing that his partner or his parents can do.

Florida law, like many state laws, allows only a spouse or dependent child to sue for pain and suffering, the bulk of medical malpractice suits. Martin, who was partnered to Hoefen for a year and a half, is not legally recognized as a spouse in the state of Florida.

Hoefen's parents are unable to sue because Florida law only allows a parent to take such action in medical malpractice cases if the child is 25 or younger. Mark Hoefen was 27.

Although Hoefen's parents could legally sue on behalf of his estate, they say most lawyers have told them such a course of action wouldn't be worthwhile because they could not collect damages for pain and suffering. Therefore, they have been told, the lawsuit probably wouldn't even net enough money to cover legal fees.

______

ACUTELY AWARE OF THE DISADVANTAGES WE suffer from being unable to legally marry or otherwise form officially recognized relationships in most states in this country, many gay and lesbian couples take extraordinary legal precautions to protect themselves, their partners and their children in cases of disaster.

There is a lot that can be done through a lawyer and legal papers: you can have your will drawn up, you can execute a power of attorney for your partner, you can designate someone to make decisions for you should you not be able to do so yourself. You can even have legal documents drawn up to say how property and valuables should be divided in case of a breakup, or what child visitation rights the two of you agreed upon in advance.

But when it comes to medical malpractice suits, it appears that in many states, gay and lesbian people may be at the mercy of hospitals. Should a gay person's medical care go awry, survivors often are left with little to no meaningful legal recourse.

That has so far been true in a pivotal legal test case in New York.

______

NEAL CONRAD SPICEHANDLER WAS CROSSING THE street in Manhattan on a cold winter day in February 2002, when a car suddenly veered toward him and hit him. The car was driven by a mentally disturbed man who had gone on a rampage.

Spicehandler was admitted to the hospital with his leg broken in several places. It was unpleasant, but not life threatening.

Or at least, it didn't seem to be.

Days later, however, he died.

Spicehandler's partner, John Langen, visited him in the hospital on the night of Feb. 14. Langen says his partner was alert and seemed fine when Langen left at about 1 a.m.

But early the next morning, Langen got a call saying his partner had died.

Like most states, New York law gives spouses the right to sue for medical malpractice. Langen and Spicehandler had gotten a civil union in Vermont, and, through Lambda Legal, Langen has brought a case against the hospital. He is asking that he be recognized as Spicehandler's legal spouse, and thus be given the right to sue for medical malpractice.

Adam Aronson, the Lambda attorney who is handling Langen's case, points out that New York does not have a Defense of Marriage Act prohibiting it from recognizing gay marriages or unions performed in other states.

He also notes that the hospital treated Langen as a de facto spouse throughout Spicehandler's stay. In fact, Langen was the first person the hospital called when Spicehandler died.

Initially, a trial court ruled in favor of Langen in April 2003. The judge in the case pointed out that 'common-law' spouses from other states were routinely recognized as spouses under New York law, and that the gay couple should be treated no differently. However, an appeals court reversed the decision in a 3-2 ruling. The appeals court decided that the courts shouldn't be deciding if partners of same-sex couples are the legal equivalent of spouses.

______

SOME STATES HAVE DONE A BETTER JOB OF recognizing same-sex couples under the law as spouses.

In California, for example, the state's domestic-partnership law offers same-sex couples many of the rights of married heterosexuals, including the right to sue for medical malpractice in the case of the death of a partner.

And of course, in Massachusetts, where same-sex couples can marry, and in places like Vermont and Connecticut, where civil unions are an option, same-sex couples are protected.

But the Hoefen and Spicehandler examples are more the rule. They are just further examples of why it is important for gay and lesbian people to continue the battle for equal marriage rights. And equal respect for our relationships, and our lives, under the law.

Ellis has been denied any contact with the girls ever since she and her former partner, Rachel Burg, split in 2002. In the eyes of Florida law, Burg has the power to keep Ellis from the girls, because Burg is the biological mother. Under Florida law, Ellis was never a parent to the kids she loved and helped raise for so long.

______

FLORIDA IS THE ONLY STATE THAT TOTALLY bans gay and lesbian people from adopting children. But, according to the Human Rights Campaign, only seven states, the District of Columbia and jurisdictions of 16 other states allow a gay or lesbian person to adopt the child of his or her same-sex partner.

A handful of states, such as California, Connecticut, New Jersey, Washington and Pennsylvania, have family law that recognizes the roles and rights of non-biological same-sex parents and have granted those parents visitation rights after a break-up, even in cases when the children had not been adopted. But the vast majority of non-biological parents in a same-sex relationship in this country could find themselves similarly shut out of their children's lives after a break-up, just like Donna Ellis.

______

WHEN DONNA ELLIS AND RACHEL BURG FIRST MET back in 1991, both women were working as pediatric nurses at the Arnold Palmer Hospital for Children & Women in Orlando. Burg was married and pregnant with her first child. But soon after the first girl was born, Burg and her husband divorced.

Burg and Ellis fell in love.

In 1993, they moved in together. By 1995, they had purchased a plot of land together and built a home in Orange County, Fla. They named each other as the beneficiaries in their wills. And they raised the little girl together.

After a few years, the two women decided they wanted to have another child, through artificial insemination. According to Ellis, they decided Burg would be the birth mother because Ellis had rheumatoid arthritis and diabetes. It would be safer for both the child and the mother if Burg carried the pregnancy. In 1998, Burg gave birth to a second little girl. The two women gave the girl a hyphenated last name: Burg-Ellis.

In the nearly 10 years that the two women shared their lives together, Ellis estimates she spent about $200,000 on the children. Despite all this, in court depositions, Rachel Burg has insisted that Donna Ellis was never a mother to the children. Burg refers to Ellis as a 'roommate.'

______

SO FAR, FLORIDA COURTS HAVE DENIED DONNA Ellis any visitation with the children. The courts have also denied her any financial compensation for the 10 years of time and money she put into raising the kids.

Ellis' lawyer has appealed both decisions. However, Ellis' chances of winning either appeal are slim. Historically, the Florida courts have resisted recognizing 'de facto' parents, even in cases where there was a biological link, like when grandparents and parents have fought over child custody.

Ellis has offered to pay child support in return for seeing her children again. But Burg has declined that, too.

In all the media attention this case has garnered, gay and lesbian activists and family law experts have repeatedly pointed to the fact that in most of America, gay and lesbian people still cannot adopt the children of their partners. No doubt this is a huge problem, and would have protected Donna Ellis.

Activists also say this case illustrates just why gay and lesbian couples need to be able to marry, and be recognized as families.

I agree, and don't dispute any of that. But I also believe there is a component of the discussion that has been missing: the need for gay and lesbian people to act responsibly and humanely during a break-up, particularly in the current political climate.

If a couple cannot act decently toward one another during a break-up, they should at least act that way toward the kids. Depriving children of one of their parents is a devastating and cruel unfairness.

Going through a break-up is always emotional, and perhaps it is unrealistic to hope that gay and lesbian people would behave better than straight couples. However, there is a particular ugliness when someone like Rachel Burg uses anti-gay laws to her benefit. There is a deep hurt to all of us knowing that a lesbian uses state-sanctioned homophobia in a fight against her former partner, a woman she clearly once loved. I find it particularly repugnant when a gay or lesbian person uses anti-gay laws against another one of our own.

______

FOR NOW, DONNA ELLIS CAN ONLY HOLD ONTO the photos and DVDs that fill 16 shoeboxes and a heavy heart with memories of her children. She refuses to give up hope that, one day, she will once again be able to see the two daughters she loves so much.

But it's so hard, Ellis told the Orlando Sentinel, because the girls 'are still out there … but I can't be a part of their lives.'


This article shared 5825 times since Wed Jan 25, 2006
facebook twitter google +1 reddit email

Out and Aging
Presented By

  ARTICLES YOU MIGHT LIKE

Gay News

VIEWS Mike Johnson: The smiling face of Christian tyranny 2024-02-14
- Mike Johnson wants to rewrite the constitution to make the United States a Christian nation. James Michael Johnson, Republican from Louisiana's Fourth District, is the 56th speaker of the United States House of Representatives. He was ...


Gay News

VIEWS Parents, not legislators, should be making decisions about medical options for children 2024-02-06
By Jeffery M. Leving - No matter the medical issue, when it comes to kids, Ohio Governor Mike DeWine said something last December that every lawmaker in the country should realize when it comes to medical decisions for children. "Were House ...


Gay News

SHOWBIZ Sundance items, Green Day, 'Wednesday,' Queerties, 'The Wiz' 2024-01-26
- At the Sundance Film Festival, Jodie Foster told Variety that the $1.4-billion success of Barbie helps confirm that Hollywood no longer views women directors as too much of a risk. She said, "With a big success ...


Gay News

VIEWS Is the Pope Catholic? Francis faces opposition in steps toward LGBTQ+ inclusivity 2024-01-02
- The recent change in Vatican policy allowing priests to bless same-gender couples has provoked an unprecedented backlash against Pope Francis and his openness to LGBTQ+ people—a backlash that some fear might devolve into a schism in ...


Gay News

Bring Chicago Home: Guess who's saying no again 2023-12-04
Commentary by Bob Palmer and Mark Swartz - Chicago is ushering in an era of change with a new progressive mayor with a vision to invest in communities long ignored and a significant increase in like-minded city council members. We are excited to see ...


Gay News

Pope Francis's community of transwomen 2023-11-28
- It's a rare opportunity to meet the pope. It's even rarer if you're a transgender Catholic. However, on Nov. 19, in Torvaianica, Italy, a community of transwomen, many of them sex workers, were welcomed and seated ...


Gay News

Banning the Banning of Books: Illinois and California lead the way 2023-10-26
- In June, at the Harold Washington Library in Chicago, Governor JB Pritzker signed legislation banning book bans in Illinois public libraries. This legislation, initiated by Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias, passed the Illinois House and ...


Gay News

OPINION Renewing state's Invest in Kids program is investing in anti-LGBTQ+ hate 2023-10-23
- In February 2020, Bishop Thomas Paprocki of the Diocese of Springfield warned transgender students in the Diocese's educational system that they "may be expelled from the school" if they live their lives authentically. Lansing Christian School ...


Gay News

Gilbert Baker Foundation reacts to death of shop owner who flew the rainbow flag 2023-08-29
--From a press release - In response to the murder of Laura Ann Carleton over flying the Rainbow flag in her shop in California, the Gilbert Baker Foundation released the statement below. Facebook refused to post the statement as it did not "...meet their standards." ...


Gay News

VIEWPOINT U.S. higher education under siege; freedom of inquiry and speech at risk 2023-07-03
- The Covid pandemic threw a harsh spotlight on higher education in America, exposing forces eating away at the foundations of college and university learning, calling into question the traditional purposes of such education in our post-modern, ...


Gay News

Guest essay by Florida mom Nicole Pejovich: What's Happening to Florida's Public Schools? 2023-06-19
Related video below - A queer Florida parent answers questions about recent laws, how Floridians are coping, and how you can help Books pulled from school library shelves by the dozens. All evidence of inclusivity stripped from classrooms. The politically ...


Gay News

VIEWPOINT For divorced parents, transgender children's health can present tricky dilemmas 2023-06-12
- Over the last few months, issues impacting individuals who identify as transgender and non-binary are getting a lot of attention in the media and among some politicians. Sadly, because it's become a political issue; a lot ...


Gay News

VIEWPOINT War in the 21st Century: mercenaries, private military companies, private armies 2023-05-20
- In 2022, $407 billion of the Pentagon budget—representing half of that year's funding —were obligated to private contractors, of which a significant number were Private Military Companies (PMCs) involved in ...


Gay News

VIEWPOINT Telling the world about my mental health disorders 2023-05-04
- Over the years, coming out as a lesbian hasn't been that hard for me—because I was always too busy hiding something else. Confessing queerness can be a breeze compared to revealing mental illness. But I decline ...


Gay News

VIEWPOINT German bishops endorse blessings of same-sex couples: Ancient rituals retturn 2023-03-31
- This March, at a national meeting of leaders of the German Catholic Church (referred to as a synod), a document titled Blessing Ceremonies for Couples who Love Each Other" received overwhelming support: 176 votes in favor, ...


 


Copyright © 2024 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. PDFs for back issues are downloadable from
our online archives.

Return postage must accompany all manuscripts, drawings, and
photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no
responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.

All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago
Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) will be treated
as unconditionally assigned for publication purposes and as such,
subject to editing and comment. The opinions expressed by the
columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators are
their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times
(a Chicago Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender News and Feature
Publication) does not indicate the sexual orientation of such
individuals or groups. While we encourage readers to support the
advertisers who make this newspaper possible, Nightspots (Chicago
GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay, Lesbian
News and Feature Publication) cannot accept responsibility for
any advertising claims or promotions.

 
 

TRENDINGBREAKINGPHOTOS







Sponsor


 



Donate


About WCMG      Contact Us      Online Front  Page      Windy City  Times      Nightspots
Identity      BLACKlines      En La Vida      Archives      Advanced Search     
Windy City Queercast      Queercast Archives     
Press  Releases      Join WCMG  Email List      Email Blast      Blogs     
Upcoming Events      Todays Events      Ongoing Events      Bar Guide      Community Groups      In Memoriam     
Privacy Policy     

Windy City Media Group publishes Windy City Times,
The Bi-Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 • PH (773) 871-7610 • FAX (773) 871-7609.