Windy City Media Group Frontpage News


home search facebook twitter join
Gay News Sponsor



DOMA hearing held involving widow beneficiary case
by Carrie Maxwell, Windy City Times

This article shared 3876 times since Wed Apr 4, 2012
facebook twitter pin it google +1 reddit email

The motions for the interpleader action case (Cozen O'Connor, P.C. v. Jennifer J. Tobits, et al. and Estate of Sarah Ellyn Farley) involving a same-sex widow's pension plan proceeds were heard by Judge C. Darnell Jones II of the United States District Court, the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, March 12.

Sarah Ellyn Farley worked for six years as an attorney in the Chicago offices of Cozen O'Connor.

Tobits and Farley were married in 2006 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.

In 2010, Farley died at the age of 37 from a rare form of cancer.

Cozen O'Connor filed a lawsuit claiming that the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) prevents them from recognizing Tobits as the beneficiary of Farley's pension-plan death benefits. Their argument says that DOMA applies to private companies as well as the federal government. The firm has asked the court to determine who should receive the death benefits, Tobits or Farley's parents.

Tobits then filed a breach of fiduciary duty counterclaim against Cozen O'Connor, alleging that if the firm did not intend to recognize same-sex spouses, it had a duty to inform Tobits of that fact. Tobits wants to be recognized as the legal surviving spouse and beneficiary of her late wife's pension plan proceeds.

Farley's parents are also challenging the legality of the couple's marriage under DOMA, saying that Cozen O'Connor's pension plan is Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA)-qualified. ERISA is a federal mandate, however, and does not define the word "spouse."

Farley's parents never approved of her daughter's sexual orientation nor her marriage to Tobits.

Tobits has already been appointed as administrator of her late wife's estate by an Illinois probate court. In the Illinois case, the court rejected the Farley's claim that their daughter was single, and ruled that Tobits and Farley were legally married and entitled to all the rights and protections given to spouses under state law.

Cozen O'Connor's pension plan states that a spouse is a person to whom an employee has been married for at least one year. The pension plan does not indicate that the same-sex spouses are excluded from participating. Additionally, the law firm has several offices in states where same-sex marriage is legal, and also has diversity and non-discrimination policies that include sexual orientation.

At the hearing, the court asked all of the involved parties to address the constitutionality of DOMA. Both the United States Department of Justice (DoJ) and the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group (BLAG) of the House of Representatives have intervened in the case and are also parties.

The DoJ, under President Obama's instructions, is no longer defending the constitutionality of DOMA.

BLAG, under the direction of Speaker of the House John Boehner, R-Ohio, has convened to defend DOMA in the courts, and is doing so in this case.

The National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR) and co-counsels Teresa Renaker and Julie Wilensky of Lewis, Feinberg, Lee, Renaker and Jackson, P.C.; and Benjamin L. Jerner, Tiffany Palmer and Rebecca Levin of Jerner and Palmer, P.C. represented Tobits in court.

H. Robert Fiebach of Cozen O'Connor's Philadelphia law office represented the firm in court while Thomas Brejcha and Peter Breen from the Thomas More Society, Randall L. Wenger from the Independence Law Center and Jonathan W. Michael from Burke, Warren, MacKay and Serritella, P.C. in Chicago are representing the Farleys.

During the hearing, which lasted more than four hours, Minter said, "An attorney from the U.S. DoJ appeared to argue that if DOMA applies in this case, then DOMA is unconstitutional and an attorney from BLAG argued in defense of DOMA."

The court also heard from Susan Katz Hoffman, an ERISA expert from Little Mendelson, who argued that DOMA does not prevent an employer from voluntarily providing benefits to a same-sex spouse, and that if an employer does not intend to do so, the employer must make that clear. Hoffman also wrote an amicus brief on behalf of the Human Rights Campaign, arguing that DOMA does not apply to this case.

"Judge Jones was very engaged and seemed to understand that Cozen's position, that DOMA prohibits private employers from recognizing same-sex spouses, would unsettle thousands of existing private pension plans," said Minter.

"We hope the judge rules that DOMA does not apply to private benefit plans and that Cozen O'Connor must give Farley's death benefit to Tobits, as required by the plain language of the plan," said Minter, adding, "The U.S. DoJ agrees that DOMA does not apply to private employers, and is also arguing that if the judge holds that DOMA applies here, then DOMA violates the equal protection clause of the federal constitution and should be struck down. We strongly agree that if DOMA applies, it is blatantly unconstitutional and should be struck."

If the court decides that DOMA applies to a private companies' (Cozen O'Connor) benefit plan and awards the benefits to the Farley's the ruling will extend DOMA to non-governmental actors. Currently, DOMA defines the terms "spouse" and "marriage" only in federal laws and regulations.

A ruling in this case is still pending and may not be handed down for a number of months.

This article shared 3876 times since Wed Apr 4, 2012
facebook twitter pin it google +1 reddit email


Gay News

WORLD Japan ruling, Kenya groups, World Cup, Almodovar 2022-12-04
Video below - A district court in the Tokyo Prefecture ruled that Japan's constitutional ban on same-sex marriage is legal, according to The Washington Blade. In a statement to Reuters, plaintiffs' attorney Nobuhito Sawasaki said, "This is actually a ...

Gay News

NATIONAL Trans officials, marriage equality, Karl Schmid, Pelosi, Buttigieg 2022-12-04
Video below - Once all of the newly elected officials are seated, there will be nine transgender state legislators (up from eight this year) and nine non-binary state legislators across the country, NBC News noted, citing The Victory Institute. ...

Gay News

Landmark step toward equality: Senate passes bipartisan Respect for Marriage Act 2022-11-29
-- From press releases - WASHINGTON — The Human Rights Campaign (HRC) — the nation's largest lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ+) civil rights organization — today celebrated the bipartisan passage of the Respect ...

Gay News

NATIONAL Respect for Marriage Act, lesbian judge, gay official resigns 2022-11-20
- Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-New York) said that debate on the Respect for Marriage Act (RFMA) is suspended and will continue on Nov. 28, when the Senate reconvenes after Thanksgiving, LGBTQ Nation reported. The RFMA ...

Gay News

Senate marriage equality bill advances with 62-37 bipartisan vote 2022-11-16
- A bipartisan group of U.S. Senators voted 62-37 for cloture—the end of debate—for the Respect for Marriage Act (RMA), signaling passage in the near future for the measure that enshrines marriage equality into federal law. The ...

Gay News

Rights advocates: Nov. 16 Senate vote a 'backstop' against SCOTUS overreach 2022-11-16
- Representatives from HRC and GLAD met with media virtually the morning of Nov. 16 to discuss the implications of the Respect of Marriage Act. That legislation, scheduled for a Senate vote the same day, codifies marriage ...

Gay News

Reports: Senate to vote on marriage equality law Nov. 16 2022-11-15
- The U.S. Senate will vote on a measure enshrining marriage equality into law Wednesday, according to reports. Supporters of the measure, known as the Respect for Marriage Act, which aims to protect against an eventual repeal ...

Gay News

WORLD Indian judge, marriage items, LGBTQ+-friendly countries 2022-11-13
- A judge who could pave the way to legalizing marriage equality in India took charge as chief justice, Bloomberg reported. As a judge on the top court, Justice D.Y. Chandrachud was a member of the five-member ...

Gay News

Actress Rebel Wilson gets engaged, announces birth of first child [UPDATE] 2022-11-05
- Actress Rebel Wilson (Pitch Perfect) is engaged to girlfriend Ramona Agruma after dating for seven months, according to Page Six. ...

Gay News

Last Mexican state approves marriage equality 2022-10-27
- On Oct. 27, Mexico's northeastern border state of Tamaulipas voted to recognize same-sex marriage, making it legal in every district in the country, Reuters reported. In its official Twitter account, the congress of Tamaulipas approved the ...

Gay News

Calif. judge rules for anti-LGBTQ+ baker in wedding-cake case 2022-10-24
- In California, a judge has ruled in favor of a bakery owner who refused to make wedding cakes for a same-sex couple because it violated her Christian beliefs, according to a U.S. News & World Report ...

Gay News

Singapore moves to legalize male same-sex relations, protect definition of marriage 2022-10-21
- On Oct. 20, Singapore's government filed bills in parliament seeking to decriminalize sex between men, and to amend the constitution to prevent court challenges to laws and policies concerning marriage, Reuters reported. The proposed legislation in ...

Gay News

Slovenia legalizes marriage equality, adoption 2022-10-05
- Slovenia has become the first Eastern European country to legalize same-sex marriage and adoption. The historic moment has come about after a six-to-three Constitutional Court decision in July said that same-sex marriage and adoption are constitutional ...

Gay News

Cuba legalizes same-sex marriage 2022-09-26
- Cuba has legalized marriage equality after Cubans voted in favor of a family code that increased protections for minorities on the island, CNN reported. With 94% of the votes counted as of 8 a.m. CT on ...

Gay News

NATIONAL Marriage bill, drag queen dies, Dutch queen visits, university sued 2022-09-18
- A bipartisan group of senators trying to pass same-sex marriage protection legislation pushed a vote until after the November election—a move the officials say increases their chances of success but avoids forcing the GOP on record ...


Copyright © 2022 Windy City Media Group. All rights reserved.
Reprint by permission only. PDFs for back issues are downloadable from
our online archives. Single copies of back issues in print form are
available for $4 per issue, older than one month for $6 if available,
by check to the mailing address listed below.

Return postage must accompany all manuscripts, drawings, and
photographs submitted if they are to be returned, and no
responsibility may be assumed for unsolicited materials.
All rights to letters, art and photos sent to Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago
Gay and Lesbian News and Feature Publication) will be treated
as unconditionally assigned for publication purposes and as such,
subject to editing and comment. The opinions expressed by the
columnists, cartoonists, letter writers, and commentators are
their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of Nightspots
(Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual and Transegender News and Feature Publication).

The appearance of a name, image or photo of a person or group in
Nightspots (Chicago GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times
(a Chicago Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender News and Feature
Publication) does not indicate the sexual orientation of such
individuals or groups. While we encourage readers to support the
advertisers who make this newspaper possible, Nightspots (Chicago
GLBT Nightlife News) and Windy City Times (a Chicago Gay, Lesbian
News and Feature Publication) cannot accept responsibility for
any advertising claims or promotions.







About WCMG      Contact Us      Online Front  Page      Windy City  Times      Nightspots
Identity      BLACKlines      En La Vida      Archives      Advanced Search     
Windy City Queercast      Queercast Archives     
Press  Releases      Join WCMG  Email List      Email Blast      Blogs     
Upcoming Events      Todays Events      Ongoing Events      Bar Guide      Community Groups      In Memoriam     
Privacy Policy     

Windy City Media Group publishes Windy City Times,
The Bi-Weekly Voice of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Trans Community.
5315 N. Clark St. #192, Chicago, IL 60640-2113 • PH (773) 871-7610 • FAX (773) 871-7609.